Idiot Wind (New York City Sessions 1974)
Unreleased Blood on the Tracks Take
Apart from the opening lines*, this early version of Idiot Wind strikes me as the genuine sound of adulthood - suspicious of victories, hesitant at happiness, harshest on the nearest & dearest. You know? Or do you know?
Youth is an unsustainable state of certainty. Mine was. This is not an admonishment. Youth is such a state. Growing up is to realize your own idiocy, & still be unable to overcome it. That’s the catch. It’s easy to pass each clue as if it were another block in the road between you & the finish line… when young. Later you learn the road is a cement sea & there are finish lines all around you, wherever you choose to sleep. You realize you’re already tangled in the tape of a thousand finishes & suddenly it’s not so easy to understand where this whole crazy thing is headed.
Dylan sheds his attitude in this version - a confessional, really. It’s hard to tell the difference between his insults & his pleas. Are they different? Maybe it was too uncomfortable, as history knows this song from a very different angle. The released version was re-recorded in Minneapolis w/modified lyrics & a backing band. The confessional becomes a blazing insult. Simpler & more sure of itself. A powerful front. A fake.
I miss certainty. I’ll tell you all a secret: I would love to tear someone apart again… just hang an insult in the air & walk away w/a clean mind. Next steps. A clean mind gets harder as time wears on. You lose your notion of “the good guy” in an objective sense but you never lose the need to feel vindicated. So every ill word you speak becomes a double-edged sword that cuts you up just as much. To win is to be left alone w/your unending parade of thoughts, which is no kind of trophy.
Despite this, & maybe in spite of this, happiness does exist. Happiness exists in abundance. Progress exists. Kindness. Love. Somehow these all exists. & it makes you dizzy w/wonder. This is the sound of adulthood. I’m just writing it down here for a day’s worth of progress.
* The first verse is a somewhat not-relatable tirade against the media, however, I’ve always thought this bit was among Dylan’s finest stories:
They say I shot a man named Grey / & took his wife to Italy
She inherited a million bucks / & when she died it came to me
I can’t help it if I’m lucky…